| First | Second | Third | Honorable Mention |
|
| Fall 2011 | George Washington | Capital | Shady Spring | Charleston Catholic
Hurricane James Monroe Mount View Riverside Riverview Woodrow Wilson |
| Fall 2010 | George Washington | Bluefield | Riverside | Capitol |
| Fall 2009 | George Washington | Capital | Bluefield | Charleston Catholic Mountain State Acad. |
| Fall 2008 | George Washington | Capital | Woodrow Wilson | Bluefield |
| Fall 2007 | Capital | George Washington | Sherman Wyoming East |
Bluefield Riverside Sissonville South Charleston Van Jr./Sr. |
| Fall 2006 | Capital | George Washington | Wyoming East | Bluefield Riverside Hurricane Independence |
| Fall 2005 | Capital | George Washington | Herbert Hoover | Charleston Catholic Hurricane Riverside Scott Winfield |
| Fall 2004 | George Washington | Woodrow Wilson | Winfield | Bluefield Herbert Hoover Hurricane Nitro Riverside Sissonville South Charleston |
| Fall 2003 | George Washington | Woodrow Wilson | Hurricane | Bluefield Independence South Charleston |
| Fall 2002 | Woodrow Wilson | George Washington | Bluefield | Herbert Hoover Hurricane Riverside Sissonville South Charleston Winfield |
| Fall 2001 | George Washington | South Charleston | Bluefield | Charleston Catholic Herbert Hoover Hurricane Riverside Scott Sissonville St. Albans Woodrow Wilson |
| Fall 2000 | George Washington | Charleston Catholic | Woodrow Wilson | Bluefield Herbert Hoover Riverside Sissonville South Charleston |
| Fall 1999 | George Washington | Woodrow Wilson | Riverside | Clay Herbert Hoover Sissonville South Charleston |
| Fall 1998 | George Washington | Woodrow Wilson | South Charleston | Charleston Catholic Clay Herbert Hoover Independence Sissonville |
| Spring 1998 | George Washington | Independence | Charleston Catholic Poca |
Herbert Hoover Midland Trail Sissonville South Charleston |
| 1997 | Charleston Catholic | Sissonville | Herbert Hoover Independence |
Capital East Bank Gauley Bridge Hurricane Midland Trail Parkersburg South Shady Spring Sherman Winfield Woodrow Wilson |
| 1996 | Herbert Hoover | Capitol | Parkersburg South St. Albans |
East Bank Fayetteville Gauley Bridge Meadow Bridge Mount Hope Poca Sherman |
| 1995 | Sissonville | Woodrow Wilson | Independence Meadow Bridge |
East Bank Herbert Hoover Mount Hope Sherman Valley Van |
| 1994 | Woodrow Wilson | Valley | Independence Winfield |
Capital Fayetteville Gauley Bridge Herbert Hoover Hinton Meadow Bridge Mount Hope Parkersburg South Sherman Sissonville Van |
| 1993 | George Washington | Gauley Bridge | Hinton Woodrow Wilson |
Buffalo Capital A Capitol B Greenbrier West Herbert Hoover Hurricane Independence Midland Trail Mount Hope Valley Van Winfield |
| 1992 | Herbert Hoover | Hinton | Gauley Bridge Valley |
Dupont East Bank Greenbrier West Independence Meadow Bridge Shady Spring Van Winfield Woodrow Wilson |